Why isn’t my Fragment showing? A quirk of FragmentTransactions

March 26, 2015

I stumbled upon an interesting situation while working on an Android project. I was trying to display two different Fragments at the same time, but one of them wasn’t showing up and I wasn’t getting any feedback as to why it wasn’t showing up. I was also unable to find any documentation that might explain why it was happening.

In the Android ecosystem, a Fragment is a self-contained portion of the user interface, which may or may not have graphical components. For those Fragments that do have graphical components, they can be inserted into a View in an Activity using a FragmentTransaction. A FragmentTransaction keeps track of one or many add, remove, or replace operations you want to perform in a single transaction.

An interesting quirk comes into play if multiple operations are performed in a single FragmentTransaction. Let’s say you have two fragments, FragmentA and FragmentB. Let’s add FragmentA to fragmentContainerView1, a View in an Activity:

getSupportFragmentManager().beginTransaction()
 .add(R.id.fragmentContainerView1, fragmentA)
 .commit();

Later on, we want to perform a transaction where FragmentA is placed in fragmentContainerView1 and FragmentB is placed in fragmentContainerView2. However, FragmentA may or may not still be in fragmentContainerView1.

Let’s attempt to perform this operation:

getSupportFragmentManager().beginTransaction()
 .replace(R.id.fragmentContainerView1, fragmentA)
 .replace(R.id.fragmentContainerView2, fragmentB)
 .commit();

If FragmentA weren’t currently in fragmentContainerView1, then this operation will proceed as expected and both Fragments will be placed in their respective Views. However, if FragmentA is currently in fragmentContainerView1 then the first replace() operation wouldn’t go through since FragmentA is already there. What will also happen is that the replace() operation for FragmentB will not go through. There isn’t any warning or indication that FragmentB’s replace() operation did not go through other than that it won’t show up in the expected View.

To prevent this from happening, simply check if the fragment has been added yet or not, and if not, then perform the replace, like so:

FragmentTransaction fragmentTransaction = getSupportFragmentManager().beginTransaction();

 if (!fragmentA.isAdded()) {
 fragmentTransaction.replace(R.id.fragmentContainerView1, fragmentA);
 }

 if (!fragmentB.isAdded()) {
 fragmentTransaction.replace(R.id.fragmentContainerView2, fragmentB);
 }

 fragmentTransaction.commit();

If you are experiencing a problem similar to this, you might just be encountering a situation where one of the operations in your FragmentTransaction is failing and is causing the other operations to fail as well.

Joseph Kreiser
Joseph Kreiser
Software Developer

Stay in the loop with our latest content!

Select the topics you’re interested to receive our new relevant content in your inbox. Don’t worry, we won’t spam you.

Michigan Software Labs joins the Inc. 5000 list of fastest growing companies in the U.S.
Press Release

Michigan Software Labs joins the Inc. 5000 list of fastest growing companies in the U.S.

August 12, 2020

Michigan Software Labs has earned its first recognition in Inc. magazine’s influential Inc. 5000 list. The list represents a unique look at the most successful companies within the American economy’s most dynamic segment—its independent small businesses.

Read more
Chicago Roboto 2020: A Virtual Success
Android

Chicago Roboto 2020: A Virtual Success

January 19, 2021

Looking back on last year’s Chicago Roboto, it was a great opportunity to learn while spending time hanging out with teammates. So, when it was announced that this year’s event was going to be virtual, it was hard not to be disappointed. Then again, with so many great speakers lined up, there was still plenty to look forward to.

Read more
Press Release: University of Michigan partnership
Team

Press Release: University of Michigan partnership

March 19, 2019

Michigan Software Labs announces new University of Michigan partnership to expand talent pipeline

Read more
View more articles